ACCME Reaccreditation with Exemplary Status!
The
Colorado Foundation for Medical Care (CFMC) is pleased to announce that
it has been successful in the Accreditation Council for Continuing
Medical Education (ACCME) reaccreditation process and has been awarded
the status of ACCREDITATION through March 2012. CFMC has demonstrated
compliance with ACCME’s Essential Areas, Elements, Procedures & Policies
plus achieved the highest designation of exemplary compliance in
Essential Area 3: Administration. For over 14 years, CFMC has dedicated
themselves to providing non-educational tools, services, and quality
improvement to educate and support the health care professional
community.
Based on the ACCME’s review of CFMC’s CME Unit it was determined that
CFMC’s organizational framework provides the necessary resources to
support its mission, exceeds the standard of practice thus CFMC was
awarded the highest achievement in this area, that of Exemplary
Compliance. The ACCME noted areas of this structure by saying, "Through
your ongoing participation with your QMS program, you are able to show
that you have document and record control procedures, policies and
procedures, working documents and instructions for each specific task
performed." These documents play an important role in helping our Joint
Sponsors meet the ACCME requirements as well as providing a basic
structure for improved continuing education activities.
CFMC is an active Joint Sponsor of educational activities that are
intended to improve patient care by maintaining, developing or
increasing the education, knowledge and professional performance of
physicians and other health care providers. This reaccreditation
confirms CFMC’s commitment to our Joint Sponsors. We continually strive
to improve the quality and value of our education program and services
to you and your learners. Our staff is dedicated to this work as your
partners for change. Together we can achieve improved patient care
through education.
ACCME Raises the Bar
CME,
New ACCME Criteria for 2008 and Beyond (Part II)
In the previous article on the new ACCME criteria we looked at the
new criteria model and how it works over time. The ACCME is working to
align providers’ goals with learners’ goals. This is the intention of
CFMC as well, in order to meet these new criteria CFMC will be updating
tools and services to allow their Joint Sponsors to meet and exceed the
expectations of the new ACCME criteria. These changes will take place
over the next several years to allow providers the opportunity to
implement changes and to educate CE planners on the new criteria.
There are nine criteria considered to be level 1 criterion. These are
a basic, entry-level, set of criteria used to determine provisional
accreditation with the ACCME.
Level 1 Criterion
- The provider has a CME mission statement that includes all of the
basic components (CME purpose, content areas, target audience, type
of activities, expected results) with expected results articulated
in terms of changes in competence, performance, or patient outcomes
that will be the result of the program.
- The provider incorporates into CME activities the educational
needs (knowledge, competence, or performance) that underlie the
professional practice gaps of their own learners.
- The provider generates activities/educational interventions that
are designed to change competence, performance, or patient outcomes
as described in its mission statement.
- The provider develops activities/educational interventions
independent of commercial interests.
- The provider appropriately manages commercial support.
- The provider maintains a separation of promotion from education.
- The provider actively promotes improvements in health care and NOT
proprietary interests of a commercial interest.
- The provider analyzes changes in learners (competence,
performance, or patient outcomes) achieved as a result of the
overall program’s activities/educational interventions.
- The provider gathers data or information and conducts a
program-based analysis on the degree to which the CME mission of the
provider has been met through the conduct of CME
activities/educational interventions.
Level 2 includes all nine criteria from level 1 and adds six more
criteria to complete the level. The move to level 2 criteria is a
major step being undertaken by all CME providers to become compliant
over the next several years. CFMC is currently operating at 100% on
this level. Changes in tools and services provided are being
developed to bring this compliance to completion. CFMC is finding
that their Joint Sponsors are adapting to the changes easily as the
department works diligently to educate planners and to evolve the
process.
Level 2 Criteria (all of Level 1 plus):
- The provider generates activities/educational interventions
around content that matches the learners’ current or potential scope
of professional activities.
- The provider chooses educational formats for
activities/interventions that are appropriate for the setting,
objectives and desired results of the activity.
- The provider develops activities/educational interventions in
the context of desirable physician attributes (e.g., IOM
competencies, ACGME Competencies).
- The provider identifies, plans and implements the needed or
desired changes in the overall program (e.g., planners, teachers,
infrastructure, methods, resources, facilities, interventions) that
are required to improve on ability to meet the CME mission.
- The provider demonstrates that identified program changes or
improvements, that are required to improve on the provider’s ability
to meet the CME mission, are underway or completed.
- The provider demonstrates that the impacts of program
improvements, that are required to improve on the provider’s ability
to meet the CME mission, are measured.
Level 3 includes all criteria from levels 1 and 2 and
incorporates seven additional criteria. Level 3 is considered to be
Accreditation with Commendation, the highest level of accreditation
achievable. CFMC is working towards incorporating level 3 criteria
as well as achieving full compliance with level 2 criteria. Becoming
compliant with level 3 criteria will ensure the continuing education
program to be operating at a level that allows our Joint Sponsors to
excel in their CE efforts.
Level 3 Criteria (all of Level 2 plus):
- The provider operates in a manner that integrates CME into
the process for improving professional practice.
- The provider utilizes non-education strategies to enhance
change as an adjunct to its activities/educational interventions
(e.g., reminders, patient feedback).
- The provider identifies factors outside the provider’s
control that impact on patient outcomes.
- The provider implements educational strategies to remove
overcome or address barriers to physician change.
- The provider builds bridges with other stakeholders through
collaboration and cooperation.
- The provider participates within an institutional or system
framework for quality improvement.
- The provider is positioned to influence the scope and
content of activities/educational interventions.
CFMC is refining their non-educational tools and services on a
national effort to assure your activities are meeting all new
requirements and to expand on the value of your continuing education
program. These changes are a positive way to impact the quality of
patient care through continuing education. If you have any comments
or questions on this series please contact Lorraine Pickrell by
email at lprickrell@cfmc.org.
Repurposing
Brings New Impact
Expand Your CE Impact: Enduring Materials
This Enduring Materials installment of the Expand Your CE Impact
series provides more information to CE Planners on how to repurpose
previously completed activities. The use of this method provides your
busy learners with new and more efficient ways of learning to suit their
immediate needs. It is often a time and resource-saving use of CE
efforts. Any enduring material created from a live activity is
considered a new and separate activity and thus must comply with all
appropriate requirements. The February/March 2008 issue of this
newsletter reviewed the use of Online enduring material CE; this issue
will focus on other enduring materials including CD-ROMs, DVDs,
audiotapes, multi-media, and printed monographs.
The ACCME defines enduring materials as, “…a non-live CME activity
that "endures" over time. It is most typically a videotape, monograph,
or CD Rom. Enduring materials can also be delivered via the Internet.
The learning experience by the physician can take place at any time in
any place, rather than only at one time, one place, like a live CME
activity. There are special provider-to-learner communication
requirements for enduring materials because of the nature of the
activity. Because there is no direct interaction between the provider
and/or faculty and the learner, the provider must ensure that specific
information, relative to the activity, is communicated to the learner
prior to the learner's participation in the activity.” Online enduring
material CE was covered in detail in the February/March 2008 issue of
this newsletter so this article will cover other forms of enduring
materials.
CD-ROM – A CD-ROM can have various uses as an enduring material. It
can house an audio taped activity, an interactive or multi-media
presentation etc. Higher market demand has reduced the cost of producing
CD-ROMs in both small and large quantities making this medium an
effective use of resources.
Videotape or DVD - These mediums are excellent uses of distributing
recordings of a previously conducted live activity as a new CE activity.
It is important to determine if you will use this form of enduring
material as an activity prior to conducting your live activity. This
will allow you to videotape your live activity in a way that will be
most conducive to reproducing it as an enduring material on a videotape
or DVD. While both methods are still acceptable, it is good to note that
new technologies are making it easier and more cost efficient to produce
DVDs of your videos rather than using videotapes.
Audio Recordings (Cassettes or CDs) – Recording the audio portion of
your live CE activity can enable you to reproduce the activity as a new
enduring material activity. Audio recordings have a special convenience
because they do not require a monitor for viewing the material. When
creating the recording of an activity, make sure microphones are
properly in place. Testing microphones before your activity begins will
ensure a quality recording to be reproduced as an enduring material
activity later on. You may also choose to invite your speakers to either
reproduce their teachings directly to audiotape at a later time or have
them narrate a multi-media or interactive presentation.
Multi-media or Interactive presentations – The use of multi-media and
interactivity in learning is increasing in popularity. Using slides,
audio recordings or narrations, even video clips from live activities
make excellent additions to any multi-media presentation. Creating an
interactive presentation allows the learner to be active during the
learning activity and can often develop into self-directed learning.
Multi-media incorporate various mediums into one presentation or
activity such as audio, video, and text. This enables you to provide
your learners with multiple learning styles, i.e., auditory,
kinesthetic, and visual learning in one activity.
Printed monograph – A printed monograph is often a book or pamphlet
that is most likely written by a specialist on a specific topic. A
monograph is a complete compilation and does not continue in a series or
installments such as magazines or journals. Reproducing materials from a
live activity, as a printed monograph might be more time consuming than
other methods described here but may also be valuable for learners who
do not have immediate access to equipment such as CD and DVD players.
Because enduring materials have little or no communication during the
learning period, the provider of the activity must impart the following
information prior to the start of the educational activity:
- Who are the principal faculty and what are their credentials;
- What is the medium or combination of media used in the activity;
- What is the method of physician participation in the learning
process;
- What is the estimated time to complete the educational activity
(same as number of designated credit hours);
- When is the original release date and when is the most recent
review or update (date); and
- When is the termination date (the date after which the enduring
material is no longer certified for credit)?
Release, review, and termination dates will provide your learner with
a timeframe about the educational material within the enduring material
activity. It is important to remember that policy requires providers to
review enduring materials at least once every three years or more to
make certain new scientific developments are included in the activity.
Enduring materials cannot be accredited for longer than three years to
make sure the content is accurate and up-to-date. Also make note that
you may not enlist the assistance of commercial interests to provide the
enduring materials or to distribute them to your learners.
Because of their extended reach and convenience to educators and
learners alike, enduring materials are an excellent addition to your
toolbox of learning methods. If you would like to discuss the
development of an Enduring Material or have other questions, please
contact Lorraine Pickrell at 1-800-950-8250, ext. 3372 or visit
www.yourCEsource.org for more information.
Variety in Professional Credit
CFMC is a national accredited provider of CME and CNE. We also
partner with other organizations on a regular basis to bring you
professional credits for NAHQ, AAFP, and Pharmacy. For more information
please call Lorraine Pickrell at 1-800-950-8250, ext. 3372 or visit us
on the web www.yourCEsource.org.
Talk Back
As part of a quality improvement organization, it is our goal to
continually strive for improvement. If you have comments or suggestions,
we would like to hear from you. Visit us at www.yourCEsource.org or
contact Jen Naused at 1-800-950-8250, ext. 3139, email
jnaused@cfmc.org.
CFMC Upcoming Educational Activities
Visit www.yourCEsource.org for a complete list of
upcoming educational activities. |